Neoconservatives, the Iraq Debate and Ad Hominem Attacks
06/27/14
James Joyner
Domestic Politics, Security, United States, Iraq
While those who advocated for the Iraq War were wrong, ad hominem attacks make for poor debate.
The stunning success of the Islamic State in Iraq and al-Sham
has renewed American interest in a country where we fought almost
continuously for over two decades before pulling the plug in December
2011. Suddenly, old debates have begun again and new ones have arisen as
to "who lost Iraq" and what, if anything, the United States should do about it.
On
our television screens and op-ed pages, some familiar faces and names
have again been talking about Iraq, including former Vice President Dick
Cheney, former Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz and former
Iraq Coalition Provisional Authority administrator Paul Bremer, along
with various neocon pols and pundits who never went away. Some are now
arguing that, having gotten Iraq so spectacularly wrong the last time,
these people should not be listened to now. That idea is both misguided
and dangerous.
In
full disclosure, while I had an infinitesimal fraction of the impact on
the public debate as those in question, I was among those who got Iraq
wrong in 2003. I was the reverse John Kerry, in that I was opposed to
the war before supporting it. The early arguments made by Wolfowitz and
company, focusing on Saddam's evil character and his long past use of
chemical weapons against his own people, struck me as a poor
justification for war. Despite having opposed virtually every
significant U.S. military intervention of the past quarter century,
though, I was eventually persuaded that regime change in Iraq was
necessary. In the wake of North Korea joining the nuclear club and the
sudden dwindling of American options on the Peninsula, I believed a
nuclear-empowered Saddam was an unacceptable risk.
While
I've long since acknowledged that the war was a mistake and eschewed
the nation-building campaign almost from its outset, it took me longer
than most who write under the TNI masthead to advocate withdrawal, for a variety of reasons too complicated and tangential to this column to go into here.
Read full articlehttp://nationalinterest.org/feature/neoconservatives-the-iraq-debate-ad-hominem-attacks-10761
No comments:
Post a Comment