From Stalwarts to Scapegoats: America's Foreign Clients
06/27/14
Ted Galen Carpenter
History, Security, Politics, Global Governance, United States, Iraq, Vietnam
"We must stop portraying foreign political figures in heroic terms, only to repudiate those same figures when they predictably fail to live up to our fantasies."
As forces of the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) conquer major chunks of Sunni-inhabited areas in Iraq
and advance on Baghdad, it has become fashionable among U.S.
politicians and pundits to place the blame for the latest debacle at the
feet of Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki. Just a few years ago, though,
those same opinion leaders hailed him as the symbol of a new, democratic
Iraq. Maliki’s journey from Washington-backed national savior to scapegoat is a familiar one.
Time
and time again, U.S. leaders and their media allies have anointed a
Third World political figure as the latest Great Pro-Western Democratic
Hope, only to become disillusioned when that leader fails to live up to
Washington’s unrealistic expectations. Then, that leader becomes the
cause of everything that has gone wrong in his country, combined with
the implicit assumption that a change of leadership would make the
troubling developments go away. It is a lazy, naïve style of foreign
policy that ignores far deeper causes of instability in many of Washington’s client states.
The
transformation of Maliki’s image from one of a democratic statesman to a
divisive and inept sectarian political hack is similar to what has
occurred in Afghanistan, another arena of dashed U.S. nation-building
aspirations. In the years immediately following Washington’s ouster of
the Taliban regime in Kabul, U.S. officials portrayed Hamid Karzai
as someone who was committed to forging a modern, democratic
Afghanistan. A few critics in the United States derided him as little
more than the mayor of greater Kabul, and argued that his ability to
stay in power at all was heavily dependent on the continued backing of
U.S. occupation forces. American enthusiasts of Karzai’s rule, however,
summarily dismissed such cynical observations.
Read full articlehttp://nationalinterest.org/feature/stalwarts-scapegoats-americas-foreign-clients-10759
No comments:
Post a Comment