What Homer's Iliad Tells Us about a U.S.-China War
08/24/14
Stephen Fallon
History, Literature, Military Strategy, Defense, United States, China
What lessons does ancient Greece offer us if the unthinkable comes to pass in Asia?
Despite its status as one of the oldest works of literature in the Western canon, Homer’s Iliad
boasts enduring relevance. Though it recounts the legend of the Trojan
War, it has three key lessons to teach the American strategist who seeks
to navigate the Asia-Pacific region.
The
Asia-Pacific is experiencing a period of strategic flux in which China
is attempting to erode American primacy. War is not likely in the short
term, but the risk of conflict will grow if Beijing continues its
economic and strategic trajectory. While the region and the world will
look to leaders in both countries to mitigate the effects of strategic
competition, The Iliad has something to teach us about what may
prompt a regional conflict, the risks entailed in seeking to prosecute
such a war and how the contest could be resolved.
Homer’s compatriot, Thucydides, in his History of the Peloponnesian War, famously suggested that fear initially drove Athens to expand its empire, while honor and interest followed afterwards. The Iliad, however, highlights that honor can be the primary driver of conflict.
The
Greeks were driven to an amphibious invasion of Troy to satisfy honor.
Paris, a Trojan prince, stole Helen from her husband, Menelaus.
Agamemnon, leader of the Greeks and Menelaus’ brother, vowed to bring
her home. To satisfy this point of honor, he risked the lives of his
men, his allies and his own power. By any reasonable standard, this was a
disproportionate response. To be sure, Agamemnon would also have been
attracted by the prospect of glory and riches, but the loss of Helen and
the desire to retrieve her was the casus belli.
Read full articlehttp://nationalinterest.org/feature/what-homers-iliad-tells-about-us-china-war-11139
No comments:
Post a Comment