The ISIS Challenge: A Tough Problem, Even Tougher Solutions
08/15/14
David C. Hendrickson
Counterinsurgency, ISIS, Security, Iraq, United States
The Islamic State presents the Middle East and America with an immense challenge. The possible solutions won't be easy to implement.
The
use of U.S. military force against ISIS is a significant escalation
whose long-term significance is elusive. The announced justification for
the military strikes combined a humanitarian rationale (the exigent
need of the Yazidis stranded on their bleak mountain) with the threat
that ISIS posed to American citizens in the Kurdish capital of Erbil.
These objectives cannot quite be taken at face value. Humanitarian
interventions have a strong tendency to morph into something much larger; there is, moreover, a deep obscurity in what the Obama administration intends to do. President Obama has identified a vital interest, but has also put some limits on the enterprise.
He emphasized that “there is no American military solution to the
larger crisis in Iraq. The only lasting solution is for Iraqis to come
together and form an inclusive government—one that represents the
legitimate interests of all Iraqis, and one that can unify the country’s
fight against ISIL.”
The
American airstrikes occur against the background of a prolonged
stalemate over the formation of a new Iraqi government. Nouri al-Maliki,
who has recently announced that he will step aside,
whose parliamentary list received the most seats in the elections, has
incurred the bitter enmity of the Kurds and the Sunnis; even a majority
of the Shia legislators has abandoned him. Iran opposes him; the United
States opposes him; Sistani opposes him. Faced with these obstacles, it
seems incredible that Maliki should have stationed personally-loyal
military forces at critical points around the capital in a display of
force, as his answer to the call of the Iraqi president—a Kurd—to nominate Haider al-Abadi for prime minister in preference to Maliki.
(Maliki is also objecting to the very presidential discretion that
enabled him to remain prime minister in 2010, when Allawi earned, but
was denied, the right to form a government.) It is a very ill omen that
the Shia should display such division even when their community lies
under mortal peril.
Read full articlehttp://nationalinterest.org/feature/the-isis-challenge-tough-problem-even-tougher-solutions-11081
No comments:
Post a Comment