How We Won the Cold War, but Lost the Peace
http://nationalinterest.org/feature/how-we-won-the-cold-war-lost-the-peace-1119709/04/14
Nicolai N. Petro
Post-Conflict, Foreign Policy, History, Diplomacy, Russia, Ukraine, United States
"The key emotional and cognitive transformation that must be achieved, and that was not achieved by this first post–Cold War generation, is to recognize that Russia is an inalienable part of Europe."
To
have any hope of healing the deep wound in the very heart of Europe
that is the crisis in Ukraine, we must first separate two crises that
have become intertwined. One is the crisis of Ukrainian statehood. The
other is the crisis of Russian relations with the West.
The
crisis of Ukrainian statehood cannot, in fact, be resolved by Western
intervention. One reason is that even the most generous package of
Western assistance imaginable is still an order of magnitude too small to stabilize the entire Ukrainian economy.
Another reason is the West’s persistent failure to grasp that the
current crisis is not the result of the civil war. Rather, the civil war
is the result of the failure to resolve fundamental issues of national
identity and statehood in a manner that satisfies both Russian- and
Ukrainian-speaking Ukrainians. The fateful decision by Western
governments to back one interpretation of Ukrainian nationhood in its
effort to dominate over the rest merely ensures that this conflict will
continue for decades to come.
The
second crisis that of Russian relations with the West is the result of
the unfortunate decision to hold relations with Russia hostage to the
success of Ukrainian statehood. Since the success of a Ukraine identity
whose conceptual roots rest in a relatively small and highly localized
portion of the population (Galicia) is far from assured, such a linkage
can only lead to the deterioration of relations to the point of outright
hostility and confrontation. Having put all their eggs in the Ukrainian
nationalist basket, however, both the current government in Kiev and
its Western supporters now have every incentive to blame Russia for any
and all failures.
But
while the current crisis has a precise origin—the overnight disavowal
by the foreign ministers of Germany, France and Poland of the February 21 transfer of power agreement signed between president Yanukovych and the opposition—it has been over twenty years in the making.
Read full article
No comments:
Post a Comment